The Brabant village Oisterwijk and Operation Market Garden

The Battle for ‘s-Hertogenbosch from the German perspective

Documents for 28-10-44

712 I.D.
712 I.D.

The destroyed ‘s-Hertogenbosch train station and houses along the station square after the final German counterattack on 28 October.

2/3 of San.Komp.712 (Medical Company 712) was taken prisoner on 24 October in ‘s-Hertogenbosch-north.

In this picture the Company is marched off behind other German POW and taken to Coudewater In Rosmalen were the British had a large field hospital.

The German documents with the outcome of the battle for 28 October 1944.
(Click on the documents to enlarge)

28-10-44   The build-up of the defensive position was accomplished without enemy

action. It was apparent that the enemy pulled back some of its forces as no tanks were

sighted anymore since the evening of 27.10. The MLR’s right flank was located at the

south-west corner of the harbour, at the north-west exit of the city. The here deployed

company’s were constantly under the attack of Machine Gun, Mortar and Artillery fire

and suffered ongoing losses.


                 The Division held the defensive position at the flooding area’s at the

causeway Vlijmen-Engelen suitable and the ditches in front of the right flank and

the for the enemy almost coverless area’s for approach favourable for defence.


                 The enemy finally tried to cautiously advance with 2 armoured

reconnaissance vehicles along the road ‘s-Hertogenbosch-Vlijmen around 17.00 hrs but

after the bridge was blown the vehicles pulled back. A shock troop, that was advancing

from the MLR’s right flank at the north-west edge of the city with the intent to connect

with the forward deployed troops at Groot Deuteren, was able to destroy 2 military

utility vehicles at Groot Deuteren and capture and bring back important enemy maps.


                 The division pull back of own units out of the defensive position west of

‘s-Hertogenbosch followed in the night of 28./29.10. What’s left over of the Division

after this is;


Division Staff (losses more then 25%)

Signal Battalion 712 (losses more then 30%)

1 strong mixed Infantry Battalion from G.R.732, 745 and Fus.BTL.712

Staff of A.R.1712 with 1 mixed Staff detachment with, 1 Battr.F.K.39 with 3 Guns

                                                                            1 Battr.1.F.H.18/40 with 3 Guns

                                                                     And 2 Personnel battr.


20 men from the at the command road positioned Pz.Jg.Kp.712

Felders.Btl.1712 with Staff and 3 Companies (the 4th .Company is lacerated in the battle

                                                               in  ‘s-Hertogenbosch)


Medical troops (2/3 of Medical Company 712 taken prisoner by the British on 24.10. in



                 During the Battle from 22. – 27.10.44 the 712th and troops assigned to the

712th at least destroyed;


             29 tanks (of which 14 by Panzer-Faust)

             1 tank shot immobilised

       and 2 armoured reconnaissance vehicles destroyed.



                 The division summarizes the following result after the big battle:


                The Infantry of our own Division was already defeated during the first day’s

of the big battle by two complete and well equipped British Divisions (of which one

Armoured-Div.) While carrying out the orders the Division adequately defended it self.

The not organically organized air force-battalions could not consolidate during the battle

and because of this fell apart.


                 The Division was not adequate equipped with communication equipment to

act as static division, especially the Command of the Artillery suffered of this. It already

became clear in October, during several shock troop deployments, that the communication

radio’s for the Artillery usually failed. Furthermore, the greatest part of the

communication radio’s of the VB ( forward deployed artillery observers) failed.


                 Further more it became apparent that after tree big battles the men had

become careless.


                 The scattered troops did not deploy fully battle hardened men and the

worst soldiers where for the greatest part scattered. The Division prevented the enemy to

push trough over ‘s-Hertogenbosch to the west because of their sacrificing battle.


Our own artillery was much to weak at the beginning of the big battle and the ammunition

stock not sufficient. Later on the Staff of the Artillery Regiment was not in the position

to command an lead their Artillery Battalions by use of radio equipment.


                The Panzer-Faust 44 proved sufficient though it doesn’t replace the heavy

anti armour shells. Also the Infantry Division needs a sturmgeschutze as a mobile

weapon in the point of the attack.


                The new British flame-throwing tank greatly contributed to the success of

the enemy because the infantry soldier at only some instances could defend himself

against this weapon with a Panzer-Faust.


                There was a shortage in M.G. equipment. During the beginning of the battle

the Divisions Companies only had the use of 5-6 M.G. and were for the greatest part

already destroyed during the artillery’s pre-bombardments.



A further cause for the great losses for the Division are to be found in the command.

Since May until 21.10.44 and also during the big battle the Div. 22 Commanders and

Battalion Officers of the Artillery were either lost in battle or transferred. During the

course of the big battle, 1 Regiment Commander, 1 Regiment Officer and 2 Battalion

Officers of the divisions own troops were missing. More unfavourable was the situation

for the Companies and Platoons. Therefore its necessary for the Division to relieve them

and form new ones. Therefore a sufficient buildup period is favourable to let the

replacements and officers get used to one another and to let them get used to the new

structure and new weapons. A refresh in deploying forces with only march battalions

will at this moment, for the state the Division is in, not be a foundation for a full worthy

Battle Division. After redeployment of these forces the Division will be in the position

again to full fill its obligations and to achieve proud successes again.







15 Army



General Command of 88 Army Corp

General Command of 84 Army Corp

Ia/War diary